Autoimmune encephalitis
Since 1974, Mitsuda and Fukuda[9] described "atypical psychosis" as some acute and transient psychotic disorders, which cannot be easily classified as either schizophrenia or mood disorder with psychotic features. Some important clinical characteristics of atypical psychosis include acute onset, emotional and psychomotor disturbances, alternations of consciousness, high prevalence in women, and well-adjusted premorbid personality. In these conditions, an involvement of neurologic brain changes has been hypothesized.
The identification of autoimmune encephalitis, a new category of neuropsychiatric diseases that occur with focal or widespread involvement of the nervous system in association with antibodies against extracellular epitopes of neuronal cell-surface or synaptic proteins, have led to changed paradigms for the diagnosis and treatment for some neuropsychiatric disorders, and reclassification of syndromes previously defined as idiopathic or with descriptive terms.[10] Since 2005, there has been 1-2 discoveries of novel syndromes and associated autoantigens per year, including autoantigens the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (NMDAR),[11,12] the subunits Kv1.1 and Kv1.2 of the voltage-gated potassium channels (VGKCs), the α-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazol-propionic acid receptor (AMPAR),[13] mGluR5 (metabotropic glutamate receptor 5),[14] or the γ-amino-butyric acid B-receptor (GABAbR),[15] Lgi1 (leucine-rich glioma inactivated 1),[16] CASPR2 (contactin associated protein 2).[17] The study of these disorders has revealed novel mechanisms of how antibodies might alter memory, behavior, cognition and cause mood disorders, psychosis, seizures or abnormal movements.[18,19] However, though obtaining serum to test for autoantibodies is extremely convenient and relatively non-invasive, the caveats of using serum antibodies as a diagnostic tool need to be considered. Neuronal surface antibodies are not 100% specific.[20-25] In particular, lower serum titres should be interpreted with caution, and the role of evaluating cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) neuronal surface antibodies rather than serum titres may increase diagnostic specificity.[10] The presence of neuronal surface antibodies should always be correlated with the clinical picture.
One important clinical feature of autoimmune encephalitis is the strong association between autoantibody production and the presence of teratoma or other neoplasms. Comorbidities of autoimmune encephalitis with small cell lung carcinoma, neuroblastoma, ovarian carcinoma, breast carcinoma, thymoma and testicular cancers have also been reported.[26] These findings suggested that the autoantibody syndrome may be triggered by cross-reaction between antibodies produced in response to tumor presence and antigenically similar synaptic proteins within the central nervous system (CNS). Autoimmune encephalitis can develop, however, with or without an underlying tumor, and in the largest case series to date, no teratoma or other type of tumor was detected in 41% of cases.[3,27]
Different forms of autoimmune encephalitis can affect patients of all ages, although some of them seem to preferentially occur in late childhood and young adulthood.[28,29] The onset of the symptomatology shows a substantial overlap among the different types. Sometimes associated with headache or mild hyperthermia, the initial clinical picture is characterized by a rapid development of a set of psychiatric and/or neurological symptoms. Mood disorders, usually manic or mixed-manic symptoms, anxiety, behavioral problems, psychotic features, mild to moderate disorders of consciousness and memory loss occur in most types of autoimmune encephalitis, often associated with seizures. Demographic information (such as gender and race), presence or absence of a underlying tumor, brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) examination, and the severity and predominance of some symptoms over others can suggest a specific subtype.
Ultimately, two approaches have been proposed for the diagnosis of autoimmune encephalitis: one based on the laboratory examination as proposed by Lancaster and Dalmau[10] and the other based on clinical diagnostic criteria as proposed by Zuliani et al.[30] The latter recommend that one should suspect a diagnosis of an autoimmune encephalitis when a patient presents with acute or subacute onset of symptoms, evidence of inflammation supported by CSF examination, imaging, or histopathological investigations, and the exclusion of other infectious, metabolic, and toxic etiologies. Supportive criteria include a history of other autoimmune comorbidities, and preceding infectious prodromes. Using a combination of these criteria as well as test of response to therapy, they suggest a model whereby patients can be classified as having definite, probable or possible neuronal cell surface antibody related pathology.[30,31]
Anti-NMDAR Encephalitis
Anti-NMDAR encephalitis, among all the autoimmune encephalitis, is the best understood variant and the most frequently associated with almost exclusively psychiatric presentation. The illness was first described as a distinct clinical entity in an observational study in 2005 by Vitaliani et al.[11] in four young women who developed acute psychiatric symptoms, seizures, memory deficits, decreased level of consciousness, autonomic instability, and hypoventilation in association with the presence of an ovarian teratoma. Two years later, a paper by this group described the underlying pathology, mediated by auto-antibodies directed against the NR1 subunit of the NMDAR.[12] These antibodies cause a decrease in the number of NMDARs in target cells by inducing cross-linking and internalization of NMDARs by autophagy.[32] Therefore, anti-NMDAR encephalitis represents a state of NMDA-R hypofunction, associated to glutamate dysregulation.[33] Initially, it was classified as a paraneoplastic syndrome[12] due to the strong association (upwards of 60%) with a teratoma or other tumor types.
Although many patients have been diagnosed with anti-NMDAR encephalitis to date, the exact prevalence of this disorder is unknown. A study of 100 patients revealed that although most patients are young women, the disorder can occur in men and children.[34] In fact, with increasing awareness of the syndrome, the number of pediatric cases has steadily grown and appears to represent about 40% of all cases.[28] The younger the patient, the less likely an underlying tumor will be detected at the time of presentation.[34]
A stereotypical clinical course with different phases is noted for patients with anti-NMDAR encephalitis.[35] In 70 % of patients, the illness begins with a prodromal phase lasting 5-14 days.[3,36] This non-specific flu-like prodrome is characterized by subfebrile temperature, fatigue, malaise, headache, nausea, diarrhea, vomiting. This is followed by other clinical phases, which may vary in sequence, presentation and severity.
After the initial phase, psychiatric manifestations go on to develop, including emotional and behavioral disturbances such as apathy, anxiety, panic attacks, fear, depression, decreased cognitive skills, sleep disorders. In most cases, an excited manic or mixed manic symptomatology develops in a variable lapse of time, from hours to days; mood disorders and agitation are almost invariably associated with psychotic features such as grandiose delusions, Capgras syndrome, paranoid interpretation and different types of hallucinations. From mild to moderate cognitive disorders are frequently presented.[18,37] During this phase, patients are often referred to psychiatric assessment, and may receive treatment with psychoactive agents or admission to psychiatric facilities.
This psychotic phase can be followed by physical decompensation involving autonomic instability (less common in children), with hypo- or hypertension, hypo- or hyperthermia, hypoventilation, cardiac arrhythmia, decreased responsiveness, and occasionally short-term memory loss. Some patients may also have seizures, most commonly generalized tonic-clonic, but also partial and/or complex type. In some patients early treatment with antiepileptic drugs may mask seizures. Dyskinesias, extrapyramidal signs and stereotyped motor automatisms may also be observed.[38] During this phase, patients not already admitted to hospital often present to the emergency department because they no longer follow verbal commands, and may appear mute (with language disintegration) and akinetic. Patients may maintain gaze as if in a catatonic state, smile inappropriately, or demonstrate stereotyped athetosic movements.[34,39]
Since the initial descriptions, further studies have expanded the clinical phenotype of this syndrome. Some patients with anti-NMDAR antibodies have predominant or isolated psychiatric features, dystonia, or epilepsy, without the classic multistage presentation, potentially representing a forme fruste of anti-NMDAR encephalitis, mimicking a psychiatric disorder.[3,40]
The diagnosis of anti-NMDAR encephalitis is confirmed by the detection in serum or CSF of antibodies to the NR1 subunit of the NMDA receptor. After treatment or in advanced stages of the disease, the CSF antibodies usually remain elevated if there is no clinical improvement, whereas serum antibodies may be substantially decreased by treatments. The titer of CSF antibodies appears to correlate more closely with the clinical outcome. Patients with anti-NMDAR encephalitis may have abnormalities of both CSF and MRI. 80% of patients with confirmed anti-NMDAR encephalitis have abnormal CSF with the majority of them exhibiting a lymphocytic pleocytosis, but over a half also show raised proteins. There may also be the presence of isolated oligoclonal bands in the CSF of patients with autoimmune encephalitis (around 60%).[3] In contrast to the consistency of the clinical picture, MRI findings are less predictable; only 55% of patients had increased FLAIR or T2 signal in one or several brain regions, without significant correlation with patients’ symptoms. MRI can be normal or demonstrate medial temporal involvement or focal areas of hyperintensity in the frontal or parietal cortex. Other studied demonstrated that [18F]-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) can show cortical hypermetabolism in acute stages, and hypometabolism in more subacute stages of the illness.[5,41] In over three quarters of patients, EEG shows generalized or frontotemporal slow or disorganized activity without epileptic discharges.[28] These findings may overlap with electrographic seizures.
Other autoimmune encephalitis
This group of autoimmune diseases can be defined as limbic encephalitis (LE). LE was first described in the 1960s in patients with severe short-term memory impairment or dementia in association with bronchial carcinoma.[42] Cardinal symptoms of LE are severe short-term memory impairment with psychiatric symptoms such as personality change, depression, anxiety, hallucinations, confusion and complex partial-often temporal or classically in LGI1 encephalitis facio-brachial tonic seizures[43] and generalized seizures[44]. Another prominent symptom, found in 40% of patients and also exhibited in mice lacking LGI1,[16] is myoclonus.
Anti-AMPAR encephalitis
AMPA receptor antibodies (Glutamate receptors- GluR1/2) can be one of the autoimmune causes of limbic encephalitis. Glutamate is one of the main excitatory neurotransmitters with GluR1/2 being the predominant AMPA subtype in the hippocampus (GluR3 is associated with the distinct disorder, Rasmussen’s syndrome). About 70% of patients have an underlying tumor in the lung, breast or thymus.[13,45] These patients develop acute limbic dysfunction that can be associated with prominent psychiatric symptoms. Most patients, commonly middle-aged women, present with subacute onset of disorientation, confusion, memory loss and aggressive behavior. CSF findings and brain MRI are similar to those of anti-NMDAR encephalitis. The long-term prognosis depends on the controlling of the tumor and presence of coexisting symptoms related to onconeuronal antibodies.
Anti-γ-amino-butyric acid beta encephalitis
This encephalitis is caused by disruption of the metabotropic GABAbR, and equally affects both sexes. These patients present with limbic encephalitis, prominent seizures and memory dysfunction.[46] About half of the patients had an associated tumor, either a small cell lung cancer (SCLC) or a neuroendocrine tumor of the lung.[15] The MRI and CSF findings are similar to those in other types of LE, with unilateral or bilateral increases in medial temporal lobe FLAIR or T2 signal consistent with LE and CSF lymphocytic pleocytosis.
Anti-LGI1 encephalitis
Although previously termed ‘anti-voltage-gated potassium channel encephalitis’ (anti-VGKC encephalitis), recent evidence suggests that actually other autoantigens (LGI1 and CASPR2) are associated with this LE.
Antibody-mediated mutation and disrupted function of LGI1 (a secreted neuronal protein that interacts with presynaptic and postsynaptic receptors) have been associated with the syndrome of autosomal dominant lateral temporal lobe epilepsy,[5,47] and have been shown to cause increased excitability, which may result in memory disturbances, confusion and seizures, with MRI findings that are usually typical of limbic encephalitis. LGI1 antibodies have been most recently associated with adult-onset brief but frequent motor events which comprise unilateral upper limb jerking and ipsilateral facial grimacing, termed "faciobrachial dystonic seizures".[43] Some patients develop hyponatremia (60%) or REM sleep-behavior disorders. Only 11% of cases are associated with a neoplasm, most commonly thymoma or SCLC.[16] In those who do have a tumour, the encephalitis can precede the identification of the neoplasm in up to three quarters of patients.[48,49]
Anti-CASPR2 encephalitis
CASPR2 is an axonal protein of the neurexin IV superfamily. Mutations in the human gene encoding CASPR2 have been associated with autism, epilepsy, obsessive-compulsive disorders and Tourette syndrome.[10] These patients usually develop symptoms of encephalitis, drug-refractory epilepsy, peripheral nerve hyperexcitability, or both (Morvan’s syndrome or neuromyotonia).[17,50] CNS symptoms include cognitive impairment, memory loss, hallucinations, and seizures.
Mood and psychotic symptoms in autoimmune encephalitis
Depending on the clinical presentation and the timing of evaluation, the psychiatric manifestations of autoimmune encephalitis can be diagnosed following DSM 5 criteria as mood disorder with psychotic and or catatonic features due to a general medical condition (GMC), but also as psychotic disorder or delirium due to GMC, where the GMC is autoimmune encephalitis. In many patients, there is no previous personal or family history of psychiatric disorders. The psychiatric presentation looks like a delirious mania or acute confusional state that develops over a short period of time, fluctuates over the course of the day and manifests with changes in cognition, affect, behaviour and perception. Initially the features may be subtle, but over days to weeks, there may be dramatic worsening, culminating in an unresponsive and catatonic state.[51]
Patients may present labile mood, with a wide range of emotions including anxiety, low or euphoric mood, irritability, apathy or changes in behaviour including agitation/restlessness alternating with episodes of somnolence.
A case of anti-NMDAR encephalitis mimicking bipolar disorder has been described.[52] More recently Steiner et al.[53] examined patients with schizophrenia (n = 121), major depressive disorder (n = 70), and borderline personality disorder (n = 38) and found that 9.9% of the patients diagnosed with schizophrenia had NMDAR-R antibodies in their serum compared with 2.8% of the depressed patients and 0% of the borderline personality disorder. Interestingly, patients with schizophrenia, who were seropositive, had immunoglobulin G antibodies not only directed against the NR1a subunit of the NMDAR but also against the NR1a/NR2b subunit again raising the question about the level of involvement the immune system might have in the pathogenesis of some forms of psychotic disorders.
Perceptual disturbances are also common, including misinterpretations, illusions or hallucinations (visual and auditory) and delusions (often pertaining to hallucinations). During the unresponsive phase, patients have been referred to as catatonic with features involving purposeless motor activity, extreme negativism, bizarre posturing, grimacing, mutism, echolalia, and echopraxia.
It has been hypothesized that in a proportion of patients diagnosed as bipolar or psychotic disorders, autoantibodies may be present during an earlier developmental period resulting in a gradual and chronic exposure to NMDA-R hypofunction.[54] Because of the similarities in symptom presentation, the possible role of autoimmunity in bipolar- and psychotic-spectrum disorders seems to represent a promising direction for future research.
Autoimmune diseases and psychotic and non psychotic mood disorders
Many evidences suggest a role of inflammatory mediators and immune dysregulations in the pathogenesis of psychiatric disorders such as BD,[7,55,56] schizophrenia,[8] depression,[57] and Alzheimer’s disease.[58]
Autoimmune diseases, as well as BD and schizophrenia, are multifactorial disorders related to an interaction between gene and environment.[59] A familial occurrence is commonly found.[60] Moreover, autoimmune reactions often advance much more slowly than immune reactions to pathogens, suggesting that control mechanisms can continue to work until a threshold has been exceeded leading to a progression from subclinical to clinically significant symptomatology as in mood and psychotic disorders. In addition, in autoimmune diseases, the mechanisms of control may temporarily restore the antigenic tolerance, leading to a cyclical pattern of exacerbation and remission of the disease. These general pathophysiological mechanisms of autoimmunity lead to common clinical features, including familial occurrence, progression from subclinical to clinical level of the symptomatology, and the exacerbation-remission periodic course. Interestingly, both affective and non-affective psychosis have been definitively shown to possess all these clinical features.
In a recent study by our group[61] on a clinical sample of 347 BD patients we found a very high prevalence (48.1%) of AAD. The result is particularly interesting for two reasons: firstly for the disproportion with the prevalence observed in the general population (in our country the estimated prevalence in general population is about 3.2% for autoimmune diseases and about 20-30% for allergic conditions);[62,63] secondly, for the lack of a difference in gender distribution, because AAD are usually more represented in women.
The association between AAD and BD has rarely been systematically investigated in clinical samples. An increased prevalence of mood symptoms have been found in a variety of inflammatory conditions, including auto-immune diseases, cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, obesity and metabolic syndrome, as well as in more benign inflammatory conditions such as asthma and allergies.[64] A large Danish cohort study showed that a history of Guillain-Barre syndrome, Crohn’s disease and autoimmune hepatitis was associated with raised risk of BD.[56] The authors concluded that autoimmune processes precede the onset of BD. A subsequent study, based on Danish hospital data, reported that a broad range of autoimmune diseases and infections requiring hospitalization increase the risk of developing schizophrenia and mood disorders.[65] The observed associations support a possible immunological contribution in subgroups of patients with severe mental disorders, such as bipolar and other psychotic disorders. However, whether it is a causal relationship or an epiphenomenon due to other environmental factors or common genetic vulnerability remains to be clarified and deserve further research. Genetically vulnerable individuals might be at a particular risk of developing mood disorders as a consequence of autoimmune reactions and inflammation affecting the brain.
Inflammatory mechanisms can affect the brain through many different pathways that are not necessarily mutually exclusive.[66-68] Peripheral inflammation can affect the brain without passing the blood-CNS barrier by proinflammatory cytokines activating the tryptophan-kynurenine pathway, regulating serotonin production together with NMDA and glutamate receptor activity and may also indirectly affect dopamine regulation.[69] The increased inflammation in autoimmune diseases may also influence the brain through increased permeability of the blood-CNS barriers, making the brain vulnerable to immune components, such as cytokines and auto-antibodies. Furthermore, brain-reactive antibodies can induce a range of psychiatric and neurological symptoms, as observed in association with antibody-induced LE.[12]
More controversial and less explored by the literature is the association we found between AAD comorbidity, generalized anxiety, and cyclothymic-anxious temperament.[61] This finding suggests a possible intriguing relationship between autoimmune mediated inflammatory process, trait emotional reactivity, and stress vulnerability.
Although the link between stress and mood disorders is well recognized,[70] there are no specific studies examining the role of stress, immune dysregulation, and autoimmunity in BD. Retrospective studies in autoimmune diseases have found that up to 80% of patients report uncommon emotional stress before disease onset,[71] and it has been suggested that immune system activation may vary across affective states in BD patients.[72] In a more theoretical perspective, it is possible to hypothesize a "constitutional" reinforcing loop between emotional/mood reactivity and autoimmune/allergic reactivity that characterizes the "usual" self of these individuals and influence the entire span of their existence.
Interestingly, in our sample, the lifetime prevalence of cancer and neoplastic diseases was very low, involving less than 1% of the patients. Recent data suggested an association between certain diagnosis and a lower-than-expected probability (negative comorbidity) of developing other disorders.[73] It has been recently suggested that the immune system and other regulatory systems, particularly the peripheral nervous system, convey signals from tumor cells to the brain that might play a part in tumor progression and metastases, through sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves, and by the modulation of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and adrenal medulla activity.[74] The majority of studies have focused on cancer and schizophrenia;[75] there are few data regarding patients with BD.[76] Although individuals with Schizophrenia and BD are exposed to more environmental noxious agents that contribute to tumor development (e.g. tobacco and alcohol) than the general population, results of several population-based studies indicate that patients with schizophrenia have a lower risk of prostate, colorectal cancers and melanoma but, a higher risk of breast and lung cancer. The increased risk for certain tumors could be associated with diverse and non mutually exclusive factors such as drug side-effects, unhealthy lifestyle, poor access to health care and differences in socioeconomic status. On the other hand, the reduced risk of other types of cancer may be explained by genetic factors, such as the increased expression of various candidate tumor suppressor genes, or the decreased expression of some oncogenes in genomic regions implicated in schizophrenia or BD susceptibility.[77,78] An alternative explanation may be related to the possibility of an increased immune reactivity in patients with BD and/or other mental disorders.[7] During the process of carcinogenesis, in fact, naturally occurring antibody responses to tumor antigens were found to be associated with improved survival and protection against the spread of cancer.[79] In recent trials on cancer immunotherapy, clinically significant antitumor responses were often associated with the induction of autoimmune toxicity.[80] This finding suggests that the same immune mechanisms that elicit autoimmunity may also contribute to the destruction of tumors.